PEEBLES Rovers have accused football authorities and Scottish Borders Council of "pricing the club out of existence" following more than a decade of unsuccessful attempts to secure a suitable ground.
The historic club's chairman Allan McDonald and vice-chairman, Dave Lamb, spoke to the Peeblesshire News of their anger and disappointment over the circumstances which led to the decision to wind up Rovers after more than 130 years of football.
The pair claim a succession of broken promises, rising costs and increasingly demanding ground regulations left the club with nowhere else to turn.
But despite the devastating outcome, they have vowed not to abandon their ambition of bringing senior football back to Peebles while the name survives after youth team Peebles FC renamed as Peebles Rovers earlier this year.
Read more
Peebles mountain runner shortlisted for British Male Athlete of the Year award
Gala Harriers secure silver and bronze medals at Kirkcaldy championships
£500 Asda grant funds Christmas celebration for Galashiels disability football team
Mr Lamb said: "We survived two World Wars and Covid, but it's a fence that's killed us."
The club's difficulties stem from changes to the East of Scotland Football League's ground criteria. Rovers, who played at Whitestone Park, were unable to meet requirements for permanent perimeter fencing while attempts to secure a groundshare with Peebles Rugby Club or relocate to a new venue were unsuccessful.
Mr McDonald said: "The catalyst was the league joining the pyramid and then the Juniors coming in. We think that's when it really hit us."
Mr Lamb argued that the regulations were excessive for clubs competing at tier eight of Scottish football, particularly given the relatively small crowds attending matches.
He said: "We get that they want to make the league as professional as possible and make grounds aesthetically good and we get all that. But does it really matter for 60-70 folk coming here on a Saturday?
"We see it as completely unnecessary for tier eight. Maybe have the rule for the Premier Division in tier six if you want and different criteria the further you go down."
The club's attempts to find a solution involved years of discussions with Scottish Borders Council and other organisations.
In 2022, a feasibility study was commissioned into developing sporting facilities around Whitestone and Violet Bank, including the possibility of relocating Rovers. However, the wider proposals failed to secure Levelling Up funding from the UK Government.
Mr Lamb said the club had also explored sharing facilities with Peebles Rugby Club at the Gytes.
He claimed the club received a signed letter from the council indicating that it would be able to play at a fully compliant facility at the rugby ground.
Peebles Rovers in action (Image: Supplied)
He said: "That wasn't our ideal situation but it was a last resort to keep us alive."
However, this ultimately proved unsuccessful, as did upgrading Whitestone Park.
According to Mr Lamb, potential funding of £200,000 from sportscotland and £400,000 from the Scottish FA was available for improvements including changing rooms and dugouts.
However, he said that funding could not be used towards the perimeter fencing required to meet league criteria.
They claim the council subsequently obtained a quotation of £275,000 for fencing works, which the club believed made the project financially unviable.
Mr Lamb said: "The council were supposedly committed to putting money in. They went to price up a perimeter fence and were priced at £275,000 so they essentially priced us out of existence by doing that."
Mr McDonald claimed he had obtained an alternative quotation of approximately £50,000 for fencing covering only the area the club believed was necessary.
He said the council's proposed works included areas that Rovers did not believe needed to be enclosed.
Mr Lamb added: "Our thought was even if the money wasn't coming from the council and we had to raise £275,000, it wouldn't have been for a perimeter fence.
"We'd have been using it for looking at a new place we could build from the ground up."
Speaking to the Terrace in September, a Scottish Borders Council spokesperson said: “Scottish Borders Council revisited the costings numerous times through the work to look at the project. The figure provided by SBC to provide the fence was £330k with potential savings of £107k bringing the possible cost to £220k.
"However, the technical report made clear that many of the potential savings were high risk and may have been non-compliant for planning purposes and also for where the Gytes is located (on a high risk flood plain and in a conservation area). The high cost of the fence became an issue with key funding partners who could not include that in any funding application, pushing the funding gap greater than previously imagined."
The club also criticised the facilities provided at the new Peebles High School, arguing that its artificial pitch could have offered another solution had it been designed to meet senior football requirements.
Mr Lamb said: "It could have been turned into a compliant facility fairly easily, we feel. There's clubs at our level who play on 3Gs attached to schools but this one doesn't meet the criteria.
"Another 50, 60, 100 grand would have satisfied all these things, we believe, and we wouldn't be where we are now."
Despite the difficulties, the chairman insisted the club had always operated within its means. Rovers did not pay players or provide travel expenses, relying instead on volunteers and support from committee members.
Mr McDonald said: "It's all about letting local lads play football on a Saturday and we live within our means and we think that's really what this level of football should all be about, not trying to be something we're not."
The decision to wind up the club was particularly painful because of the impact on younger footballers in the town.
Mr Lamb said: "The bigger picture is not just Peebles Rovers' senior team, there's kids who play here who have nothing to aspire to now, at the moment, hopefully that will change."
Mr McDonald explained that dropping into amateur football had been considered but was not viewed as a realistic option. The town's existing amateur side, Tweeddale Rovers, was already experiencing difficulties attracting players, while the club's oldest youth players were only 15 and 16.
They also believe they would have met entry criteria for the South of Scotland Football League but travel involved to compete in that league would be unviable.
He added: "There wasn't another 20 players we could call upon to field a senior team.
"Lots of people have asked if we could just have gone amateur. In theory, yes. In practice, not really.
“The ground regulations, for example, are different in the South of Scotland League. We loosely discussed whether it would be possible to join them but you’d have struggled to get a squad together that were happy to make those trips every fortnight.
“But we’re in a position where the ground regulations in tier six in the South of Scotland aren’t the same as the eighth tier in the East of Scotland and that’s just preposterous. There’s no uniformity at all and to my mind, that’s where the SFA should be stepping in and ensuring that.”
South of Scotland Football League secretary Richard Osborne confirmed his organisation’s ground criteria differs from the East of Scotland Football League, but stopped short of confirming that Peebles Rovers would have been accepted.
Although the club's immediate future has been brought to an end, the pair hope a suitable piece of land could eventually allow Rovers to return.
Mr Lamb said: "We need land that we can develop. There must be people around here, same as there was at some other places, which are effectively fields that have been developed into facilities.
"There must be people who can help us. Maybe that's what we can still push for and realistically you're looking at maybe five, six or 10 years, maybe we have something that we can raise money for and have our own place."
Mr McDonald admitted that bringing the club's existence to an end had been emotionally exhausting, saying: “It was sad. It's been sad for quite a while to be honest but it was sad to actually make it final.
"We've known for a long time that it's been coming to this."
He added: "We've been fighting this for 10-12 years and it's tiring. It's emotionally exhausting but both Dave and I have vowed that we're not going away."
Scottish Borders Council has strongly rejected suggestions that it failed to honour funding commitments to the club.
A spokesperson said: "No funding was promised as the major funding sources being applied for were external sources and outwith SBC's control.
"There was commitment given to allocating staff resource across a number of SBC departments to look at the feasibility of the project, including costed design works to meet the ground criteria set by EoSFL.
"That staffing resource has been allocated since 2023 in various forms to support Peebles Rovers."
The council confirmed its leader had written to the club regarding use of the Gytes pitch and that discussions took place in October 2023 about sharing facilities.
However, it said simply having access to the pitch did not satisfy league requirements.
The spokesperson added: "It was not until much later when fully costed plans for the required works became clear that the viability of the project was questioned (from funders and the local authority)."
The council also defended the facilities at Peebles High School, stating that the development followed sportscotland's requirements for school campus construction.
It said its officials had worked extensively to identify solutions, including preparing funding applications, developing costed plans and meeting league representatives.
The spokesperson added: "SBC's Sports Development Team will continue to provide advice and guidance on the development and infrastructure/governance of all clubs in the Scottish Borders."
Earlier this year, Tweeddale West councillor Drummond Begg put forward a motion calling on elected members to do all they can in supporting Peebles Rovers.
This was unanimously backed, with council leader Euan Jardine saying: “These are rules made up by an organisation that seems to be not influenced by the SFA, or Sport Scotland or local or national government but are making up rules that are costing clubs to go under and we will continue that fight.”
The East of Scotland Football League were contacted for comment but did not respond. Chairman John Greenhorn has previously defended the organisation's ground requirements.
He told The Terrace in September: "Our criteria are relatively basic. If Peebles Rovers felt that it was excessive, they should have brought that to the league and tried to convince enough people to vote for a reduction in the criteria.
"Every other club, including those in similar situations, have made efforts to ensure their grounds are enclosed.
"It's an unfortunate situation. We don't want to lose any clubs, especially those with a unique situation like Peebles Rovers."
Mr Greenhorn maintained in that article that Rovers had never formally raised concerns about the regulations, although the club disputes this, insisting it had held numerous discussions over the years and unsuccessfully sought special dispensation.
For Mr McDonald, the loss of senior football in Peebles represents the culmination of years of frustration.
He said: "We have thanked everyone who has stood by us and there are a lot of people, but unfortunately there's too many who could have made a difference who didn't.
"My last email to the East of Scotland and Scottish Borders Council was saying that we've been priced out of existence and I hope that you're proud of yourselves.
"Obviously we never got a reply to that."
Share