Community council urges football league to review ground rules

Peebles Rovers' Whitestone Park ground <i>(Image: Peebles Rovers FC)</i>
Peebles Rovers' Whitestone Park ground (Image: Peebles Rovers FC)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

PEEBLES Community Council has written a letter to the East of Scotland Football League (EoSFL) in support of Peebles Rovers and encouraging the organisation to reconsider ground criteria that ultimately led to the club folding.

Rovers resigned from the organisation earlier this year after being unable to secure a perimeter fence around their Whitstone Park ground – a requirement for competing in the league. With nowhere to play, the club then took the decision to fold, ending a more than 130-year history.

The community council voted unanimously to formally address their concerns with the league. In a letter addressed to EoSFL President, John Greenhorn, PCC chairman Peter Maudsley wrote: “At our October community council meeting, the committee unanimously required me to write to you with our concerns and in support of small local football clubs such as Peebles.

"Two rules relating to the entry criteria for new membership applicants are of particular concern and these rules do not appear to acknowledge the rural nature of the Scottish Borders, the general lack of alternative grounds or indeed potential planning constraints.

"The two rules causing concern are:

1. Enclosed self-contained ground such that admission can be controlled and charged for. The ‘football ground’ must give an overall appearance and impression of being a football ground.

2. The boundary wall/fence must be permanent and such as to obscure viewing into the ground from publicly accessible areas

"The present rules appear discriminatory and as written would preclude many new clubs being affiliated in rural areas and indeed in many urban areas as well. We doubt that this was the intention when the existing rules were drafted.

"The insistence that fields must be walled or fenced off so that they give an overall appearance and impression of being a football ground and that this boundary should obscure the view from outside the ground is often at odds with planning requirements.

"Small communities often share spaces for sport to allow more than one sport to be played in that area. Further, many clubs are sited on land such as council owned parks and are consequentially constrained."

The letter continued: "Where it is possible to make the required changes, we consider that the additional costs of implementation take resources away from making football more accessible to all.

"We are sure that EoSFL agrees that increased participation in sport is something that we may all regard as beneficial to society and that small local clubs are the bedrock of the game at all levels.

"Consequently, we are concerned about the potential for the unintended consequences relating to these particular rules and request that they are removed or amended from your entry criteria.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos